Haven’t opened them yet, but odor looks good.

When I think of "heavy duty," I think the liner would be substantial or thicker or tougher than a regular liner - unfortunately, that is not the case with this liner. In fact, it's much thinner than the one I replaced it with. That being said, I've only taken one shower with it and I cannot attest to its resistence to mildew - time will tell. As far as the "heavy duty" part, I would not buy this again - but...that could change depending on the mildew part. It's a THIN, gray shower liner.

Just put it up, so don't know how it will work long term. However, it seems lots better than the vinyl ones, stays in place and hangs nicely. So far, so good!

I just machine washed it today with a small amount of bleach. It looks brand new. MUCH nicer and easier than a plastic liner.

Doesn’t resist water, it gets wet, but waterproof and protects outer side of curtains/ liner from leaking on the floor. I like it so far as no problems or concerns about this product.

Fabric is solid with silky texture. Will buy these in the future as I have never seen this quality at an amazing price. Going to order more for stock up. Also, the opaqueness allows one to use this as a stand alone shower curtain.